The FAB Four—4 Cookies

The FAB Four—4 Cookies

4 Cookies • 2 Flavors • A Small Gift with Big Taste

The Fab 4 is a simple, thoughtful cookie gift featuring 4 handcrafted Blue Chip Cookies across 2 flavors — two cookies of each flavor. It’s perfect when you want to send something sweet, personal, and easy to enjoy.

Ideal for thank-you gifts, thinking-of-you moments, small celebrations, teacher gifts, employee treats, and everyday surprises.

Includes:
✓ 4 handcrafted cookies
✓ 2 flavors of your choice- 2 cookies per flavor
✓ Personalized gift message
✓ Carefully packed for freshness

Please note:
This gift includes shipping and handling.  It ships individually and cannot be bundled with other items. For multiple deliveries to a single location, please contact us at [email protected] for personalized assistance.

$17.97

Buy $100 or more and save 10%.
Choose Your Special Card
Smile, Your Day Just Got Sweeter Thank You Congrats Happy Birthday You Have My Sticker or Card On File Smile, Your Day Just Got Sweeter
Add a Signature Gift Seal

Optional

None So Happy for You +$1.00 Happy Birthday +$1.00 Thank You +$1.00 Sending Love +$1.00 Thinking of You +$1.00

Each cookie flavor you select, our system will magically put 2 cookies in your gift box...because who can resist just one?

Product Quantity
Black and White

The Black & White--Our brown sugar dough is infused with melted Oban chocolate, creating a sweet and decadent profile. Made famous by our original Fisherman's Wharf store in 1983!  

Chocolate Chip Cookie-SemiSweet

Blue Chip Cookies' Chocolate Chip Cookie is a timeless classic. Soft, buttery perfection meets an abundance of rich, melted chocolate chips, creating a cookie experience that's pure indulgence in every bite.

Chocolate Chip with Mars M&Ms

These handcrafted cookies blend our signature brown sugar dough, rich semi-sweet chocolate chips and vibrant M&M Milk Chocolate candies, creating a perfect balance of chewiness and crunchiness.

The Blue Chip Cookie Chunkster: Peanut Butter, Oats, M&Ms and Semi-Sweet Chips!

A burst of chewy oats, creamy peanut butter, melty semi-sweet chocolate chips, and colorful M&M’s all packed into one unforgettable cookie.

Cinnamon Delight, aka Snickerdoodle

Alias Snickerdoodle, pure cinnamon on the inside and outside.

Confetti Birthday Cake

Confetti Cake-Birthday Cake Extract with Carnival Sprinkles Inside! Our Leawood, KS store calls it the Hootenanny!

Cookies and Cream

Blue Chip Cookies' Cookies and Cream, alias the OMG, merges our delightful soft and chewy sugar cookie with generous Oreo chunks.

Peanut Butter wheat sensitive

Our Gluten-Free Peanut Butter is made with gluten-free flour. Please note that our gluten-sensitive cookies are made in a facility that also manufactures gluten-containing products

Cookies and Cream

Blue Chip Cookies' Cookies and Cream, also known as the OMG, is now available in our Gluten Sensitive line.  Our gluten-sensitive sugar dough rolled and pressed into gluten-free Oreos!  A great combination.

Sugar Cookie

Our Sugar Cookie is a duplication of our Sugar Cookie but made with gluten-free flour. Please note our gluten-sensitive cookies are made in a facility where gluten products are made.

Sugar M&M

Our Gluten Sensitive Sugar M&M is our sugar cookie, but made with gluten-free flour, and then we add M&Ms to it (which are gluten-free) Please note our gluten-sensitive cookies are made in a facility where gluten products are made.

Two lemon cookies on lace doily with lemon slices

A sugar cookie with lemon extract and zest!

Chocolate Cookie with Resees Pieces

A rich milk chocolate cookie layered with premium Oban chocolate and Reese’s peanut butter pieces. This cookie was created by a customer, and she named it Chocolate Peanut Butter Palooza.

Oatmeal Raisin

Fresh oats, raisins and sprinkled with a touch of coconut.

Peanut Butter wheat sensitive

Our Peanut Butter Cookie is made with smooth premium peanut butter and folded into our brown sugar dough.  We press and even put the old-fashioned fork mark!

Peanut Butter and Milk Chocolate

Our Peanut Butter Cookie with a surprise inside, this month it is Milk Chocolate!

Two cookies with colorful candies on a doily.

This combination of our classic sugar cookie with the fun and vibrant addition of colorful M&M candies.

Sugar Cookie

Sugar dough scooped and then rolled in Sugar.

Blue and white sprinkled cookies on lace doily

Our famous Sugar cookie dough is scooped into our dough balls and then rolled in seasonal sprinkles or our signature "blue sprinkle" mixture.

The Triple Chocolate Cookie

A chocolate lover’s dream with semi-sweet milk chocolate and Oban, delivering rich, gooey layers of bold and creamy chocolate in every bite.

White Chocolate Chip

Our brown sugar dough is just like the Chocolate Chip, but we replace the Guittard semi-sweet chocolate with Guittard White Chocolate chips.

Purchase this product now and earn 3 Points!

Cookie Information

A Blue Chip Cookie weighs approximately 2.0-2.25 ounces and is 3 -3.5 inches in diameter. We package two cookies of the same flavor in each pack, and on the back, we identify the flavor and ingredients with our white label. The average Blue Chip Cookie is 270 calories.  Click Here for Nutritional Values.

All of our products are made in a facility that contains the following allergens: Tree Nuts, Wheat, Milk, and Eggs.

Your cookies ship from our facility in Milford, OH—address: 5991 Meijer Drive, Suite 24, Milford, OH 45150.

TIP: If sending to multiple addresses, we recommend doing so on a Desktop, Laptop, or Tablet for optimal screen width.

Please note: You cannot send to multiple addresses in a single transaction unless you have set up an Account with Blue Chip Cookies Direct. The address Book is integral to the multiple-ship capability. It is recommended that you enter your addresses into your account first so you can assign each gift to an address during checkout.  Please set up your account first.

Step 1: ADD PRODUCTS

Add all the products you want to buy to the shopping cart. Later, you will assign each product in your cart to an individual address.
Example: You want to send 10 Premium Portfolios Bundles to 10 individuals. Put all 10 Premium items into your cart.

Step 2: GO TO CHECKOUT
During checkout, after you enter your billing information, you will see “Shipping to” with “Single Address” or Multiple Addresses.” Select “Multiple Addresses.” It will automatically take you back to your shopping cart so you can configure your packages to the correct address.

Step 3: INPUT ADDRESSES.
If you have not already created an account and entered addresses, you can do so now by going to the top of the page, where you will see “Add Addresses.”  Be sure to save your addresses and create your account during checkout, or they will not be saved for future reference.

Step 4: “SPLIT” PRODUCTS
“Split” your ten products into ten single products.  Keep splitting until you have 10 lines, each with 1 product.

Step 5: ASSIGN ADDRESSES TO PRODUCT
Once you begin “Splitting,” A column will appear on the right side where you can assign an address to each product. If you have two different products going to the same address, assign that address to each product. The system will bundle them during checkout.

THEN SAVE, bottom left, once you are done. It will take you back to the checkout page to personalize each gift, where you can select your preferred delivery date and customize a message for each recipient.

Please call us if you have any questions.