My Way Assortment (12)

  1. Home
  2. Cookie Gift Box-All Occasions
  3. My Way Assortment (12)

My Way Assortment (12)

12 Cookies ~The My Way is our best-selling cookie assortment because you create it yourself. Choose seven flavors from our list of 25+ gourmet cookie flavors. Each flavor you choose is equal to 2 cookies.  Create your own cookie assortment with the My Way Box, choose up to seven flavors.  Be sure to scroll down all the way down to the bottom of flavors to find your favorite flavors and to pick your packaging and add to cart.  Add an extra one if you want!


If you select a certain cookie, a minimum of two must be ordered.

Product Quantity
test regular product

Toffee, Guittard White Chocolate and toasted slivered almonds!

Cranberries and White Chocolate Cookie

Seasonal berries and Guittard White Chocolate

black & white

Guittard white chocolate chips with our signature Oban-infused dough offer a sweet and decadent profile.  Not like our other cookies, this is cakey and dense.

blue chip joy

Slivered almonds, coconut and Guittard semi-sweet chocolate chips.

auto draft

Guittard white chocolate chips, slivered almonds and Heath Toffee!

chocolate chip semi-sweet cookie

Guittard Chocolate Chip Semi-Sweet in our proprietary brown sugar dough! Award-winning. We were named the best Chocolate Chip Cookie in 12 Cities.

chocolate chip macadamia cookie

Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chip, Hawaiian Macadamia Pieces  

chocolate chip mint

Our cookie of the Month for March is Chocolate Chip Mint made with Guittard Chocolate Semi Sweet Chips mixed in with Andes Chocolate Mint Pieces.

Chocolate Chip M&M Cookie

Guittard Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chip and Mars Seasonal M&M.

chocolate chip pecan cookie

Guittard Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chip and Pecan pieces.  

chocolate chip walnut

Guittard semi-sweet chocolate and fresh walnut pieces.

Cinnamon delight cookie (Snickerdoodle)

Alias Snickerdoodle, pure cinnamon on the inside and outside.

coconut chew cookie

Toasted coconut and macadamia nuts.

confetti birthday cake cookie

Confetti Cake-Birthday Cake Extract with Carnival Sprinkles Inside!

deluxe cookie box

Special butter cream emulsion added to sugar dough and rolled in Oreo cookies pieces.

chocolate chip gluten free

We have found the perfect gluten free flour that is our identical flour ratio. We still use our Guittard Chocolate Chip Semi-Sweet in brown sugar dough, with real butter, eggs, and pure vanilla,

gluten free sugar cookie

Our sugar dough recipe with a simple substitution of gluten free flour for our regular flour.  Our recipe stands the test of time because it is a formula of excellence.  

lemon delight cookie

A sugar cookie with lemon extract and zest!

milk chocolate chip cookie

Guittard Milk Chocolate in our brown sugar dough.

oatmeal raisin

Fresh oats, raisins and sprinkled with a touch of coconut.

peanut butter

Premium peanut butter and brown sugar dough.

peanut butter surprise

Premium Peanut Butter and Guittard Milk Chocolate

sugar iced with seasonal sprinkles

Iced with buttercream and dipped into seasonal sprinkles.

sugar old-fashion cookie

Sugar dough scooped and then rolled in Sugar.

sugar with sprinkles cookie

Sugar cookie dough balls rolled in seasonal sprinkles.

sugar with buttercream icing

Sugar Cookie with Buttercream Icing on top!

triple chocolate

Guittard Semi-Sweet, Oban, Milk Chocolate all in one.

white chocolate chip

Guittard White Chocolate Chip, brown sugar dough.

white chocolate macadamia cookie

Guittard White Chocolate Chips and Hawaiian Macadamia Nut Pieces.

Choose from all our designer cookie boxes, we have something for everyone.

Purchase this product now and earn 3 Points!


The My Way Assortment is unique because you create your cookie assortment by selecting seven flavors from our portfolio of decadent gourmet cookies. Each flavor equals two cookies. We have over 28 flavors, so enjoy curating your special cookie box for yourself or others.  Pick your special box included in the price.


If sending to multiple addresses, we recommend this be done on a Desktop or Laptop versus Tablet or Mobile Devices.  In addition, you must register for an account with Blue Chip Cookies Direct, in order to create your address book.

Tip: Add all your addresses first to your address book through “My Account.” Then add the products and total number you will be sending to your shopping cart.  Example, 10 Sweet Treats. During checkout you will select “Multiple addresses” and it will take you to a page that you will “split” the Sweet Treat products quantity from “10” into ten “1” and then assign addresses. You can also add addresses on this page if you prefer.  Once completed and saved, continue back to checkout to personalize each gift and preferred delivery dates.  We recommend only doing 5 at a time during one transaction, more is possible.